Questions from the last standing Seychellian

[Shawn Cohen]

Congratulations to Final 3 guys.

Sydney, I admire your gameplay. As I have observed you are the new player here. And even as it is you have made it to the finals, seamlessly and didn't almost get a vote against you except for mine
That to me is awesome gameplay because you've broke through all the pre-game alliances and what not. My only question to you is, If you had it your way who would you want to see in the final 3 with you among anyone in the game?

Kelly, I did not expect you to vote me off at the last round, I would have expected a chance at least. But I guess I was wrong, I did say I understood what you did but you can't help me from feeling bitter about it somewhat, because even though people from the other side wanted you out, I kept hoping that my ties with you will help keep me in the game as far as into the finals. And that's why I stood by you. I guess I should be thankful you got me to the F4 but as I said, a chance would have been great but it never occurred. My question is had you won Immunity, who would have been going home that round?

To Brendan, so I've read in your other statement that if I voted your way the round I voted for you, you would still have ditched me. So I guess it was pointless talking to you. Anyway, we didn't really talk and I think this is a good spot for me to give you a taste of your own medicine. So please answer the following questions:

1) Compare each jury member to a survivor contestant and explain why

2)Rank the jurors in order from 1-9, 1 being the best and 9 being worst and explain why (in terms of gameplay, etc)

3) Say two good things and two bad things about each juror

4)Explain how I was somewhat, just a little bit responsible for you being where you are (just for self-gratification, haha)

5)Why did you percieve me as a threat (if you did) and why not (if you didnt). What made you think that way?

6)Pick two people on the jury and replace them with you two. Why?

7) Tell me all the lies you told me and be honest.

8) List all your alliances you had in this game

9) Tell me why you are NOT awesome

10) Tell me one move I made in the game you liked

11) What was the dumbest move in the game in your opinion?

12) Do you think we talked enough in the game to give you my vote?

13) Who is your favorite player from this ORG (you cant pick yourself)

14) Tell me why I should vote for you

Don't skip a question. I know you have answered some of them in the other threads, but I want to see you answers here.

That is all, thank you guys and good luck!

[Brendan Synnott]

Oh your evil (and bitter )

[Kelly Sharbaugh]

Mar 22, 2010 18:41:52 GMT -5 Shawn Cohen said:

Congratulations to Final 3 guys.


Kelly, I did not expect you to vote me off at the last round, I would have expected a chance at least. But I guess I was wrong, I did say I understood what you did but you can't help me from feeling bitter about it somewhat, because even though people from the other side wanted you out, I kept hoping that my ties with you will help keep me in the game as far as into the finals. And that's why I stood by you. I guess I should be thankful you got me to the F4 but as I said, a chance would have been great but it never occurred. My question is had you won Immunity, who would have been going home that round?

If it's any consolation I feel like shit for voting you out. You are one of my most loyal allies in orgs. I just couldn't vote for Sydney when I had been so close to her since day one of this game. That is the only reason. But on to your question. I don't think I could of convinced Sydney to vote for Brendan but had I won immunity I would of course without a doubt voted with you for Brendan to cause a tie and would of tried tirelessly to get Sydney to do the same. But worse case scenario I would of forced the tie to keep you in the game till the end cause I love you that much.

[Brendan Synnott]

1) Compare each jury member to a survivor contestant and explain why

Stephenie -> Jerri. She was manipulative and sneaky like her and tried to use whatever she could to get me on her side before she was voted out

Neleh -> Todd. Strategic mastermind. She was in control of the alliance on her island until we merged. She had full control over her allies, that is until we merged. But she knew how to stir the pot which i remember Todd doing in china, like when he got James out.

Jon -> Funny, he actually reminds me of Penner from the show too. A few people didn't like him, just like the real show, yet he made it far cause he made alliances and made the moves to get there. Simply Penner.

Sugar -> Stephenie from Palau, she was a strong challenge threat but her time was cut short cause people wanted her gone and there was nothing she could do about it

Ian -> Mick. Often times soft spoken, laid back personality, well liked. He was a good guy. Like Mick, Ian was closer with his alliance and wasn't too vocal, except for when he was trying to hit on Sydney lol. He remained true to his alliance like Mick, only diff. being this one screwed him.

John K -> Ian, felt he didn't deserve to stay over the others and asked to be voted out. Good guy

Christa -> Darrah, a huge threat that noone would have expected, big threat to win the game but was taken out near the end for just those reasons.

Adam -> Gregg Carey, someone who thought they were in good with their alliance but was blindsided near the end by own alllies

Shawn -> Tom Westman, someone was well liked, when i saw tom, I didnt think he was a challenge threat or anything either, kinda like shawn, but when he wants to win, he wants to win, lol. A good guy, just on the outside lookin in like this season in all stars

2)Rank the jurors in order from 1-7, 1 being the best and 7 being worst and explain why (in terms of gameplay, etc)

Shawn, there are 9 jurors....

1: Christa... challenge threat, strategic, likeable... sounds like a winner to me...
2: Neleh... only reason you left is cause you could have turned this game around in an INSTANT. the vote was more out of respect then anything.
3: Penner... you seemed to be the type in control and who knew what he was doing. You were too big a threat to let slide any further
4: Ian... stuck with his alliance, trusted them too much, got screwed cause of it
5: Adam... honestly, i saw nothing from him besides a few good challenge efforts and voting the way kelly and syd wanted him too
6:Shawn... you were too under the radar early in the game and only decided to show up late
7:John K... no offence, I don't think you played as well as you could have
8: Sugar... she didn't try hard enough to stay, her tc was probably one of the quietest
9: Steph... pre-jury boot who came in thanks to Mikey quitting I can't put her up any higher.

3) Say two good things and two bad things about each juror

Steph: sweet and smart; sometimes shes a bit too pushy and aggressive in wanting something

Neleh: Mastermind and stands up for what she believes in; gets too emotional and sometimes her way of dealing with things aren't the best

Penner: loyal and just a great guy; played the game a bit too hard and i honestly cant think of something else, i think he was hated for just playing penner, lol.

Sugar: challenge threat and quiet; TOO quiet for her own good to play this game and never talked to me in this game

Ian: Ahh what can i say about ian? hes a great guy, loyal, willing, nice. Im sorry I cant say a bad thing about him

John K: he asked to be voted out, I respect him for that, that is that.

Christa: We talked alot, I don't see ANYTHING bad in her, shes funny, smart, knows what shes doing.

Adam: threat and flirty, like me , maybe sometimes a bit too emotional when things dont go his way and gets rude, like when he was voted out, even tho i know he was just doing it for laughs afterwards.

Shawn: funny and a good time; you played too under the rader for the game and are mad at me i think


4)Explain how I was somewhat, just a little bit responsible for you being where you are (just for self-gratification, haha)

well, had you not won the challenge where adam went and you went, i might have been 4th place, so you winning that challenge was a blessing for me

5)Why did you percieve me as a threat (if you did) and why not (if you didnt). What made you think that way?

I didn't until you won final 5 immunity, you were too under the rader and i was only scared of you cause had you won final immunity, i would have been sent packing. other then that BRING IT ;D

6)Pick two people on the jury and replace them with you two. Why?

Im assuming your saying pick 3 :-p

I would say Christa, Ian and toss-up between either Penner or Neleh, depending on who had more control over others.

Christa cause she really had a huge shot at getting here and was an overall threat, Ian cause he would always stick to the people he was with. I would have to say if the other 2 were Christa and Ian, the third would be Penner, an alliance that formed early in the game, Penner got in good with people and knew how to pull certain strings. I mean its cause of him Im even here, otherwise Id be like 24th places.

7) Tell me all the lies you told me and be honest.

Saying i would vote kelly out to christa, or even think about it to certain people. Telling Penner I planned to keep our original plan for me him christa ian. Those are the ones I recall, other then that, what i told people I meant to stick to but i couldn't

8) List all your alliances you had in this game

~ Me and Penny
~ Jon, christa, Ian
~ Syd, Kelly, Ian
~ Syd, Kelly, Adam, JK
~ Tried to make one with Shawn late to save my butt the TC I went which I never intended to keep for next TC
~ Neleh and whoever she liked to bring in
~ Stephenie before she had to go and I had to vote her out
~ Tried to make a fake one with Melinda so she would blab to the others and so people would turn on her, which worked

9) Tell me why you are NOT awesome

Caz I planted my love seeds in the women and made babies, trying to play god

10) Tell me one move I made in the game you liked

Honestly, I don't remember you doing a single move, it may sound rude but its not meant to, the only thing you did was win the final 5 immunity, other then that, you were always with adam

11) What was the dumbest move in the game in your opinion?

Voting Ian out where he was

12) Do you think we talked enough in the game to give you my vote?

I think we talked quiet a bit near the end, however im not sure how much you talked to the other two so it depends on how that was.

13) Who is your favorite player from this ORG (you cant pick yourself)

Sydney... shes awesome, shes caring, shes sweet, she's nice and for coming into this game the way she did, she did a kick ass job. Not to help, but shes hot as hell

14) Tell me why I should vote for you

Cause Im awesome, I survived a harder path to get here and Kelly and Syd were together since day one, I had to wedge my way in.And cause had I not won final immunity, you might be here answering MORE then these 15 questions you asked me if I was on the jury I think i played a good game, just as good as the other two.

Thanks Shawn and good luck with your decision

[Sydney Wheeler]

Sydney, I admire your gameplay. As I have observed you are the new player here. And even as it is you have made it to the finals, seamlessly and didn't almost get a vote against you except for mine
That to me is awesome gameplay because you've broke through all the pre-game alliances and what not. My only question to you is, If you had it your way who would you want to see in the final 3 with you among anyone in the game?

Shawn- Thank you for your kind words your so sweet!
I would have liked my final 3 to have been Me, Kelly and Adam

[Shawn Cohen]

Thanks for answering the questions you three. This is a hard vote believe me. You just made the vote harder for me lol. Good luck though!

[Neleh "SourPuss" Dennis]

shawn... you were so far down kelly's pants to ever call yourself a seychellian is bullshit.

and from what i gathered throughout the game the seychellian's were fairly active and... well, nice. minus a couple people of course (like me for example)... but atleast i was active.

you were NOT a seychellian. jon and christa were more seychellian than you could ever be. while you were in seychelles you had an alliance with every single person designed to keep you long enough to go over to your friends on the other island so...


christa was the last remaining seychellian, and she did not even start on that island. you, shawn, were an empty vote in whatever direction kelly wanted, just like a lot of other people were.



and on a seperate note, everyone here is syaing you're like a nice guy or something... you're the biggest liar i saw i nthe entire game and it's turning out now that you're just a prick so... enjoy that. and whatever.

last remaining seychellian. whatever.



and why is everyone jealous of brendan? because he got to the end with the girls?

i gotta say something to make tis blatently clear to all teh guys who ever thought they stood a chance with kelly and sydney... KELLY AND SYDNEY WERE TOGETHER. THEY WERE THE PAIR. THE REST OF YOU, INCLUDING BRENDAN, WERE THIRD WHEELS...

i don't get it why everyone seems to be picking on brendan when all he did was better than any of you. from the very beginning kelly and sydney were always going to make the end of the game. if there was a third person i nteh finals that's what we all were vying for. brendan just happened to get that spot and i think he should be congratulated for it.


if y'all wanna be bitter, you should be bitter at the girls who screwed you over. or girl, because as kelly has so unsuccintly put it (meaning she's put it a thousand times already) she did everything and nobody else i nthe game lifted a finger or made any move at all. kelly is queen shit and she rules ORGs. nobody can stand a chance against kelly and she is better than all of you.



don't udnerstand the bitterness towards brendan. y'all just wish you were him.



personally i wish i was mikey b. -----> not here.

[Neleh "SourPuss" Dennis]

also just want to say thanks to brendan for his kind words. and quote this:

Cause Im awesome, I survived a harder path to get here and Kelly and Syd were together since day one, I had to wedge my way in.And cause had I not won final immunity, you might be here answering MORE then these 15 questions you asked me if I was on the jury I think i played a good game, just as good as the other two.


so true. kelly's path was paved in gold from the very beginning. how many people now has she mentioned knowing from previous games or having gotten in super close with on like day 1 or in pre-game? even penny would be where kelly is now if she had it THAT easy... i mean really, lets be honest, there's only one person there who had any difficult at all. i know because i called kelly and sydney from DAY ONE and i'd never met either of them, or anyone else that thye talked to and liked. and i continued to call it and say to EVERYONE, kelly and sydney final two but you guys just basically that's okay we like kelly and sydney and they should be final two. and that's why they're fina ltwo. you people GAVE THIS TO KELLY AND SYDNEY, brendan had to fight tooth and nail for it.


quite simple, in my opinion.




though kelly you're still awesome and i still wish you all the best and i still do think you did great it just seemed extremely easy, from where i was sitting. and when you can call it from day one and never have any doubts and then be correct, there must have been some amount of ease to it.

[Kelly Sharbaugh]

To defend myself Neleh nothing about playing survivor or any org for that matter is that easy! I did have some people I knew before this game but didn't know they were playing till the cast was full or till the game started. And the fact of the matter is only one is sitting here with me (Brendan). I did not have this game made from the start at all cause while I may think no one wanted to vote me out obviously they did. Brendan and Shawn talked about it whether they were serious or not. Christa voted for me and even tried to get others to do the same. Nothing comes easy in Orgs I didn't make it to the end cause I had friends just cause your friends with someone doesn't mean you will agree or work together every time you come across each other in a game. And I didn't come into the game with all these people in fact I was a replacement cause someone dropped out. And I don't think Brendan had any kind of struggle in this game other than having a hard time voting people out. To be honest when JK lost interest in the game I didn't feel like he should go to the end. Did I want him to get voted out? No of course not I didn't want anyone that I know to ever get voted but so after JK lost interest I planned on it being Brendan and had it of been Me, Brendan, Sydney and Adam I would of voted with Brendan for Adam and Sydney would of voted with Adam for Brendan. So truth of the matter is Brendan can say he worked harder in this game but he didn't. He was golden from the moment our island merged cause I adore him that much and He and I had planned on working together from the moment we realized we were on the same island. And yes I do think I had a lot of control in this game but let me explain it a bit better cause I don't think I controlled everyone like they didn't have a brain cause that isn't the case. What I meant is that you know round after round we'd get together and decide who was going but there were a lot of times where no one really cared who went so I stepped up and said lets vote this person out. That is what I meant by having control. Cause while people like Sydney and Brendan did play really good games there were many many rounds where they didn't want to vote someone out cause either A. Sydney didn't have the heart to do it. or B. cause Brendan wanted them to stay in longer to cater to his personal game. But yet they both did it. I am sorry if thats brutal guys but it is the truth for some of the rounds. And even I am guilty of it. I didn't want to vote out Sugar, JK, or Shawn but I did for the later two cause I had no choice really there was no other option cause of who I wanted to go to the end or, because Brendan had immunity. But Sugar was cause if I kept her in the game I felt people would target me more than I felt they were targeting me. So while Brendan can say he had a really hard time in this game he didn't was he on the outs of his original tribe for a few rounds? Yes other than that no he was set just as much as I was and just as much as Sydney was. But truth be told no one in orgs is ever set thinks contantly changed. If he can say he struggled than I am going to say I struggled cause I did put myself out there I was really good at a lot of challenges and won a lot. And I mean it's not like people didn't talk about me behind my back cause they had to of its a game. I'd be foolish to think they didn't. So in all actuality all three of us struggled in this game. Sydney struggled emotionally cause she doesn't have it in her to be aggressive and hurt others. I struggled cause I put a huge target on myself for how I was playing the game. And Brendan I feel only struggled on his original tribe cause even if I or Sydney got voted out he would not of been totally screwed.

[Shawn Cohen]

Neleh what's your problem, this is my thread and I can do anything I want with it? And I'm out am I? It's not like I am trying to win your jury vote. Don't go strutting yourself here thinking you can control the jury votes to do what you will. You don't know me and I don't know you, what I am in games is different from what I am in real life and I have nothing to explain to you because I don't care what you think about me. If you don't like me fine tell me, IM me, PM me, not attack me publicly, if anything you are the one here making a fool for yourself. Because I'm not like you and I am not a confrontational person, anyone here who knows me knows that. But you are just plain being disrespectful. And I am not gonna let you humiliate me like this in public because the only thing I ever did wrong to you was play the game the way I know how. If you don't like it fine because as I said, I am not trying to impress you nor am I trying to get your jury vote. I can do anything with my vote as much as you can do anything with yours. If you wanna campaing for your person go to all the org boards or something and bring a plackard with you, you might just be noticed somehow. Peace out Sweet Pea oh wait you're not sweet Peace out and Shut UP Sourpuss!